The University of Utah
syllabusclass noteshome workhandoutsresources FINAN1200 Personal Finance
WORRY FREE INVESTING

Basics of Investing Glossary Terms | Bond Basics and More - Bloomberg | Dollar Cost Averaging | How to put together your portfolio | Investing - Motley Fool | Investing in REITs - Bloomberg | Risk Questionnaire | What is a PE Ratio

Quote.com, 01/18/2001

Many people have asked me lately if now is still a good time to be investing in the stock market. Aren't stocks overvalued? Aren't we due for a correction, or worse, a crash? Won't the Y2K problem scare the markets? ?and so on. My answer to these questions is "Yes, and so what?"

My answer is based on over 20 years of following the market and studying the results and logic. And what all this tells me is the following:

  1. Every investor should continually keep in mind that the long-term trend of the market is up. If this weren't the case, investing in the stock market might be no different than rolling the dice, and we know there is no comparison. On a short-term basis, there might be some similarities, but short-term money probably shouldn't be invested in stocks. A basket of stocks, like the S&P 500 Index, is a reflection of our underlying economy - energy, technology, capital goods, utilities, etc. - and it's clear our economy has a terrific growth bias to it.
  2. Timing the market ? selling at a top and buying back in at the bottom is a myth. I know of no one who can successfully accomplish this consistently. Technical analysts and fundamental analysts have burned up computers trying to figure out how to do this. It's hard to be right twice on market movements; just ask Elaine Garzarelli. She is an astute market analyst who gained a lot of notoriety by calling the market crash of October, 1987, but she hasn't had much success with her calls lately. She has called for two other market corrections since, that I'm aware of, that haven't materialized. Donald Trump was another prescient investor who was written about in the press as having sold his stocks before the "Crash" in '87. But when did he get back in? He may be still in cash for all I know. If he didn't get back into the market right after the crash, he missed some of the best trading days of the decade. The market did an "about face" after the crash and began another strong move toward higher ground that continues today, twelve years later.
  3. For a 401(k) investor, there is a powerful dynamic process called "dollar cost averaging" which is involved in your investment. You have probably heard the term before, but never realized, and no one ever explained, how important a process it is. Dollar cost averaging is simply the process of investing regular amounts of money at regular intervals. This process causes the investor to buy fewer shares when the market is dear and more shares when the market is cheap. Here is an example of the process investing $100 each month.
Month Price Shares Purchased
January $5.00 20
February 10.00 10
March 15.00 6.67
April 10.00 10
Total $40.00 46.67

Average share price = $10 (40/4 = 10)
Your average cost = $8.57 ($400/46.67 = $8.57)

As you can see, after investing $100 each month or $400, your average cost of owning a share is less than the average price of the shares.

To give you some perspective of how powerful this dynamic can be, let me show you an example of dollar cost averaging through one of the most difficult times in our economic history, the Great Depression. You are probably aware of the "Crash of ‘29". This is probably the single most important day in stock market history. Not only did it conclude another great bull market run, but it also marked the beginning of one of the worst decades in our history. In the following example, I invested $1000 a year for ten years beginning in 1929 and concluded in 1938.

Year Dow Market Value Shares
1929 311 $1,000 3.22
1930 236 1,759 4.24
1931 139 2,036 7.19
1932 65 1,952 15.39
1933 84 3,523 11.91
1934 98 5,110 10.21
1935 120 7,257 8.33
1936 162 10,797 6.17
1937 166 12,063 6.02
1938 132 10,592 7.58

At the end of the decade, 1938, I had invested a total of $10,000 or $1,000 each year and my 401(k) statement showed that I had a balance of $10,592, a gain of 6% ($592/$10,000). Not terrific by any measure, until you look at the Dow Jones Average and see what happened there. It went from 311 in 1929 when I started investing and ended at 132 at the end of the ten-year period? a decline of 57%!! There you have it. The market was down by 57% at the end of ten years and I was up 6%. Not bad, considering the economic turmoil at the time.
Impact of Dollar Cost Averaging During the Great Depression

Impact of Dollar Cost Averaging During the Great Depression
                       
                       
      Year/Value
Year Investment Dow Value 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
1929 1,000 311 $1,000 $  759 $  209 $  209 $  270 $  315 $  386 $  521 $  534
1930 1,000 236   1,000 589 275 356 415 508 686 703
1931 1,000 139     1,000 468 604 705 863 1,165 1,194
1932 1,000 65       1,000 1,292 1,508 1,846 2,492 2,554
1933 1,000 84         1,000 1,167 1,429 1,929 1,976
1934 1,000 98           1,000 1,224 1,653 1,694
1935 1,000 120             1,000 1,350 1,383
1936 1,000 162               1,000 1,025
1937 1,000 166                 1,000
1938 1,000 132                  
      $1,000 $1,759 $2,036 $1,952 $3,523 $5,110 $7,257 $10,797 $12,063

The key to the success of this example is consistency. Staying the course in spite of all the prevailing economic news and views of the moment. Can you imagine the intestinal fortitude it took to continue on this course while the world around you was changing so dramatically? Could a marriage withstand such pressure? Even my pet dog would probably be disgusted with me as I continued to invest in my $1,000/year program. In addition to making money in the stock market during this decade, the rest of my portfolio (you see, I diversified my portfolio like any smart investor would) was invested in bonds, high-grade bonds. Bonds, during this time, provided investors with returns of 5-7% per year. And when you consider that prices were declining during this period by about 2% a year, my "real" returns were actually higher than these "nominal" returns. This was one time when you could have a positive real return if you put your money under a mattress!

Imagine actually making money during one of the most horrific times in our history. If dollar cost averaging can help you do that, then what are you worrying about?

Dr. Jerry Basford - The University of Utah
Webmaster Disclaimer
Dr. Basford E-Mail